The High School Musical franchise defined the tween years for many millennials. When Disney Channel released the first film in 2006, it quickly became a cultural phenomenon — the franchise generated impressive revenue, with Disney earning more than $100 million from DVD sales alone. Two sequels and several spin-offs followed, and in 2019 Disney+ revived the spirit of the series with High School Musical: The Musical: The Series, reminding a new generation and longtime fans why the Wildcats remain beloved.
The three original television movies served as a springboard for several cast members and remain enduringly popular. Recently, Ashley Tisdale (Sharpay Evans) posted a TikTok revisiting the original choreography for “We’re All In This Together,” which prompted other cast members to join and produced a viral virtual reunion. That moment underlined the franchise’s lasting appeal: once a Wildcat, always a Wildcat.
With nostalgia running high, we ranked the original High School Musical trilogy by quality and cultural impact in this special edition of Ranked.
Have an opinion? Share it in the comments or find us on social media to let us know.
3. High School Musical 2 (2007)
The second installment places third on our list. That’s not a condemnation — High School Musical 2 remains an enjoyable, energetic film aimed at its tween audience — but it doesn’t match the strengths of the other two entries.
The plot is looser and occasionally inconsistent, and when you rewatch it as an adult some scenes raise eyebrow-raising questions. Much of the story takes place at a country club owned by Sharpay and her family. Sharpay convinces her parents to hire Troy Bolton for the summer, and quickly Troy arranges jobs for his friends as well. The group’s complaints about their roles — presented in the musical number “Work This Out” — read as oddly entitled when you consider they were handed those positions without an interview or effort.
The film contains delightfully over-the-top moments and the fun of fully choreographed sequences, even when the logic behind them is thin. A memorable example is the baseball-game-turned-dance routine in “I Don’t Dance,” where Chad and Ryan sing about not dancing while performing an elaborate routine that betrays the lyrics in the best possible way.
Musically, the film shines in places. Troy’s dramatic solo “Bet On It” — set against a windswept golf course where he stomps and splashes — ranks among the trilogy’s standout numbers and was particularly inspiring for many young fans. After a season of melodrama centered on Sharpay’s pursuit of Troy and the tensions it creates, the film concludes with a heartfelt show that reunites the characters and wraps the summer on a positive note with the emotional “Everyday.”
Recommended for you: Twilight Movies Ranked
2. High School Musical 3: Senior Year (2008)
High School Musical 3: Senior Year is the only film in the trilogy released theatrically, and it made a strong impression, grossing $252.9 million at the box office. This final chapter follows Troy and his friends through their senior year as they prepare for graduation and the prospect of college — and face decisions that may send them in different directions.
Troy’s struggle between basketball and performing arts returns as a central conflict: should he pursue a basketball scholarship or follow his passion for music and audition for a performing arts program? That dilemma brings the character’s arc full circle from the first movie and gives the film an emotional core.
Musically, HSM3 steps up the complexity and intensity of its songs. The opener “Now or Never” is an energetic, attention-grabbing number, while Troy’s solo “Scream,” which follows a heated argument with his father over college choices, delivers strong visuals, choreography, and raw emotion. The film’s musical growth reflects the characters’ maturation and raises the stakes for their final year together.
While the narrative leans toward predictability — as is common in family-oriented fare — the graduation sequence and Troy’s reflective commencement speech provide a bittersweet, satisfying conclusion to the trilogy that resonates with fans who grew up with these characters.
Recommended for you: Every ‘Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street’ Song Ranked
1. High School Musical (2006)
The crown jewel of the trilogy is the original High School Musical. It all began on New Year’s Eve when Troy and Gabriella met at a ski lodge and unexpectedly sang a karaoke duet, “Start of Something New.” When Gabriella transfers to East High after the holidays, the two reconnect and begin navigating friendship, romance, and their shared love of performing as they audition for the school musical, “Twinkle Town.”
With a straightforward, heartwarming storyline that some described as a modern take on Romeo & Juliet (minus the tragedy), High School Musical is a classic teenage romance that invites viewers to root for the characters and get swept up in the excitement of high school theater.
The soundtrack remains extraordinarily catchy. “Get’cha Head In The Game” cleverly integrates basketball rhythms into its beat, and the ensemble finale “We’re All in This Together” perfectly captures the Wildcats’ camaraderie. Above all, Troy and Gabriella’s duet “Breaking Free” stands out as the emotional centerpiece of the film and one of the most recognizable songs in the series.
High School Musical set the tone for an enduring franchise and remains one of Disney Channel’s most successful original movies. At its premiere, it attracted 7.7 million viewers in the U.S., and by 2019 the movie had been viewed roughly 225 million times — a testament to its lasting cultural impact.
Recommended for you: Panic! At the Movies – An Emo Top 10 Watchlist
Written by Emma Kershaw
Support the author on social media: @emmagkershaw